
So why is this? The below advertisment stars the blonde (and yes, ditzy) singer/reality star Jessica Simpson.
Jessica Simpson Proactiv
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmYZQmX2Jz8&feature=related

This commercial is not done in an interivew-style setting, which could come off as rigid. It is slightly interview-like in nature, but her ease with the camera makes it so that it appears she is talking to her 'best friend' on the couch. Jessica even mentions "just hanging out with my friends." The makers of the Proactiv commercial are assuming we are then thinking, "Hey, I just hang out with my friends too! I relate to her." She also explains her struggle through acne.
Avril Lavigne
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4CoifDODfFg

This is for all of the Avril fans out there. Here, she is just sitting down talking to the camera. There aren't any 'over the top,' slow motion images of her splashing water on her face, smiling, and using the product. It is her talking about her personal experience with acne.
Are these advertisements effective? Is one commercial's style more effective than the other? More convincing? Why?
When you see your favorite stars telling you that a product helped them get rid of their acne, are you convinced? Is it because you trust this person who you are a fan of? Or do you just want to use a product that a celebrity supposedly uses?
Katy Perry (pop singer), Julianne Hough (country singer), and Ryan Sheckler (skateboarder)...even Lindsay Lohan (hot mess), have all been featured in their own individual Proactiv commercials. They do this because if you're a fan of pop music, you know Katy Perry and therefore some might see her as a role model. And if you're a hot mess, you'll want to use what Lindsay uses on her face.
It is basically the same reason people go out to see these people's movies, shows, or concerts...because THEY are in it. They are the reason people pay money. People pay money for these people's signatures. So advertisers know that people will be willing to pay for acne products these people have touched.
How is seeing a celebrity with a clear, acne-free face better or more convincing than a 'normal' person? Maybe people are more likely to believe an actual teenager who is explaining how they were rid of their acne. I personally feel like I would believe a real person more because when they show before and after pictures, the teens actually have really bad acne in the before picture. With the celebrities, they have to close up to see any blemishes.
Here is a still shot from Katy Perry's Proactiv commercial. Can you spot Katy Perry's acne problem, that was apparently so hard for her to deal with that she needed Proactiv? (The bottom right of the picture clearly states that it IS in fact the Before picture)

How about this teen? Can you tell they needed Proactiv?

























